I enjoyed it, as it was rather well made. The script could have used a lot of work, and the plot that supposedly drove the film was weak. In essence it could have been so much more - and you really have to be in the mood to see it!

good and not bad :)

Entertaining modern western with a great cast.

An epic tale of a boy and his pet robot!

Jennifer Aniston is great in this role, the story is just sufficient.

Blew my mind! A must see, pity they made the squeals.

A shadow of what this movie could have been. A truly sub-par western, with bad acting and an odd ending.

An amazing book. Vivid, fantastical, at times painfully graphic. A fairytale-like love story embedded in and contrasting with a contemporary setting. Worth a read

I have to dock some points for having to explain parts with text in the beginning, and for the text trying to excuse Brittany Murphy's bad British accent.

Forever straying into the very bizarre, but entertaining

Excellent characters and interaction. Not a whole lot in the way of overarching plot, but you don't miss it with this movie. Surprisingly Natalie Portman was the weakest actor in the movie, but she was still average.

Harder to kick than heroin, so be sure you want to commit before you watch. For me, the stories behind competitors and their personalities are more compelling than the music. Wouldn't be worth watching without Simon Cowell's caustic remarks.

The cast is pretty good - crazy movie. Julianne Moore and Steve Buscemi are great. The movie itself was just okay, but the ending was pretty good.

GOod movie, liked the story, however I did not like the "To be continued."

Parts of this are what a teen/young adult movie should be - not that awkward teen boy hyperbole or raunchy college romp the studios keep shoving at us. The cast was perfect except for Clark Gregg - who didn't really fit.